Comparison of Air-Cooled and Liquid-Cooled Graphite Bipolar Plates

Blog
February 27, 2025

Graphite bipolar plates are critical components in fuel cells and other electrochemical devices, serving as key elements for electrical conductivity, gas distribution, and thermal management. The choice between air-cooled and liquid-cooled bipolar plates depends on the specific application, with each cooling method offering unique advantages and trade-offs. Air-cooled plates are typically used in low-power, portable fuel cell systems where simplicity, weight savings, and cost-effectiveness are prioritized.  Comparatively, liquid-cooled plates are essential for high-power applications, such as automotive fuel cells and stationary power generation, where robust thermal management and sustained performance are critical. Hongfeng Carbon Solutions has advanced manufacturing capabilities, and extensive experience producing both air-cooled and liquid-cooled bipolar plates.  Understanding the differences between these two types is essential for optimizing applications across various industries.  By understanding the distinct characteristics and optimization strategies for each type of plate, Hongfeng Carbon Solutions guides our clients to informed decisions that meet their specific performance and operational requirements.

Learn how we optimize graphite for bipolar plates

Air-Cooled Graphite Bipolar Plates

Air-cooled graphite bipolar plates are typically used in low to medium-power or portable fuel cell systems. Common applications include small-scale backup power units such as residential fuel cell systems, unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs), educational or demonstration setups, and portable power devices. For example, in UAVs, air-cooled plates are optimal because they reduce system weight and complexity, allowing for longer flight times and easier maintenance.  They are also common in lightweight transportation and some hybrid power systems where the space and weight savings are most beneficial.

Air-cooled fuel cell systems are simpler in design and more cost-effective compared to liquid-cooled systems. They eliminate the need for complex coolant loops, pumps, and associated infrastructure, making them lighter and easier to maintain. This makes them ideal for applications where weight and operational simplicity are critical. Additionally, air-cooled plates are often more economical to produce and install, which is advantageous for cost-sensitive projects.

The primary drawback of air-cooled graphite bipolar plates is their limited heat dissipation efficiency. Air has a lower heat capacity compared to liquids. It is less effective at managing thermal loads, which can lead to uneven temperature distribution and hotspots, which can affect the longevity of the fuel cell stack. This restricts the use of air-cooled bipolar plates to relatively lower-power applications where thermal management is less demanding. They may also face challenges in maintaining consistent performance under varying environmental conditions, such as high ambient temperatures.

Advances in material engineering for air-cooled graphite bipolar plates are aimed at improving the thermal conductivity and durability of the graphite to enhance their performance in air-cooled fuel cell systems. There is also growing interest in optimizing flow channel designs to improve heat dissipation and overall efficiency.  Hongfeng Carbon Solutions uses high-purity isostatic graphite that is further enhanced to optimize the thermal and electrical properties. We have a wide range of graphite materials available and can process them in-house for resin impregnation and some composite materials.  These have the added benefits to improve corrosion resistance and electrical conductivity.

To optimize air-cooled graphite bipolar plates, Hongfeng Carbon Solutions focus on precision machining to create ultra-thin plates with intricate flow channels that enhance heat dissipation. Using high-purity isostatic graphite ensures excellent electrical conductivity and thermal performance, while advanced composites can improve durability. For example, in UAV applications, optimizing the flow channel design can significantly improve the efficiency of heat removal, ensuring stable performance during flight.

Liquid-Cooled Graphite Bipolar Plates

Liquid-cooled graphite bipolar plates are predominantly used in high-power fuel cell and flow battery systems, such as those in automotive applications, stationary power generation, and heavy-duty transportation. For example, in hydrogen fuel cell buses, trucks, and marine vehicles, liquid-cooled plates are essential for managing the high thermal loads generated during operation, ensuring consistent performance and longevity.  Large-scale fuel cells and flow batteries would typically be used to provide backup power to factories and data centers, and for grid-level energy storage under continuous operation.

Liquid-cooled systems offer superior thermal management, enabling efficient heat dissipation and higher power densities. This makes them well-suited for applications requiring sustained high performance. The use of liquid coolant allows for precise temperature control, reducing thermal stress and extending the lifespan of the fuel cell or flow battery stack. Liquid-cooled bipolar plates are also more adaptable to varying operational conditions, making them ideal for more extreme environments.

The main disadvantages of liquid-cooled graphite bipolar plates are their increased complexity, weight, and cost. The need for coolant loops, pumps, radiators, and tubing adds to the overall fuel cell and flow battery system weight and maintenance requirements. Additionally, liquid-cooled systems can encounter issues such as coolant leakage or contamination, which can impact performance and reliability.

Liquid-cooled graphite bipolar plates are seeing increased adoption in the automotive and energy sectors, driven by the growing demand for high-efficiency fuel cells in electric vehicles and demand for fuel cells and flow batteries in renewable energy systems. Hongfeng Carbon Solutions objective is improving the durability and performance of the bipolar plates to meet the demanding requirements of these high-power applications. The use of high-density graphite enhances mechanical strength and corrosion resistance. There is also ongoing research into graphite composite materials since isostatic graphite remains a preferred choice due to its excellent electrical conductivity and chemical stability. We can directly bond and apply sealant to the bipolar plates. We perform comprehensive quality testing on all bipolar plates at high pressures to help guarantee there no leakage and extended service life.

Hongfeng Carbon Solutions Perspective

As a leading manufacturer of graphite bipolar plates, Hongfeng Carbon Solutions specializes in the advanced precision machining of isostatic graphite to produce both air-cooled and liquid-cooled plates. Our expertise allows us to create ultra-thin plates and intricate flow channels tailored to the specific needs of each customer application. We offer a wide range of graphite materials, including high-purity isostatic graphite and advanced composites from suppliers like POCO, Toyo Tanso, Mersen, SGL, and more, which can be optimized for thermal conductivity, mechanical strength, and corrosion resistance.

See our graphite bipolar plates

We have pioneered ultra-thin graphite bipolar plates more than two decades ago that provided a competitive advantage to our clients.  The technology has only advanced for thinner and higher-pressure applications.  Hongfeng Carbon’s factories in China and Japan utilize state-of-the-art CNC technology and our technicians are true craftsman with many years of experience. We are also establishing a new R&D team in Japan to ensure we remain at the forefront of graphite material science.

Our ability to work with a wide variety of graphite materials allows us to customize solutions that meet the precise requirements of automotive, energy, and industrial applications. Our quality control and test methodologies are also more sophisticated than industry norms.  Much of the test equipment we use was custom developed over years of improvement to provide comprehensive evaluation and pressure testing for all bipolar plates.

Hongfeng Carbon Solutions is well-positioned to support the evolving needs of the fuel cell and flow battery industry by leveraging our advanced manufacturing techniques and material expertise. We provide high-quality graphite bipolar plates for both air-cooled and liquid-cooled systems, and have a diverse supply chain that can efficiently deliver bipolar plates from China and Japan.  Let our commitment to innovation, quality, and custom satisfaction through long-term partnerships benefit your energy system production!

Contact our team to discuss custom requirements for graphite bipolar plates.  Hongfeng will deliver prototype projects and has vast capacity for mass production.

Contact: sales@hongfengcarbon.com
Find Us: www.hongfengcarbon.com

Hongfeng Carbon Solutions is a leading provider of machined graphite components, specializing in material science & development, and advanced precision machining of graphite and carbon-based materials. As graphite experts they provide solutions for a variety of high-performance industries that utilize specialized graphite components. They use high-grade isostatic graphite from premium suppliers like POCO, Mersen, Toyo Tanso, SGL, and more. Hongfeng Carbon has also developed in-house treatments and composite materials, and are known for innovations with graphite bipolar plates, semiconductor graphite components, PECVD graphite boat, and advanced industrial components.